A Zionsville favorite for nearly 20 years, My Sugar Pie has earned its place on the Indiana Foodways Alliance Hoosier Pie, Sweet Temptations, and Coffee & Tea trails. Every pie is handmade with a light, crispy crust based on owner Kelly Maucere’s mother’s original recipe, making it a must-stop destination for a whole pie or just a little slice of heaven!

From classic fruit and creamy favorites to fun seasonal creations, there’s something to satisfy every sweet tooth on the Sweet Temptations and Hoosier Pie trails. Pair a slice with a cup of coffee for a delicious Coffee & Tea Trail stop. Can’t make it to Zionsville? My Sugar Pie also ships its handmade pies nationwide.

Hours of Operation

Tuesday - Saturday: 8:00AM to 4:00PM

Sunday - Monday: CLOSED

General Dining

Credit Cards: Visa/MC/Amex/Discover/Cash/Square

Meals Served: No Meals

Dining Classification: Casual/Carryout

Cost: Slices $6.95 plus tax, 3 Slices for $18, Whole Pies $38

Menu Style:  American

Alcohol Served: No

Separate Bar Area: No

Largest Group Served: 12

Meeting Room Capacity: 12

Discounts: Pie Plate Return Credits and Seasonal Specials

Entertainment: None

Local / Organic: Indiana Grown Certified/Pies Produced in Shop

Diet Specific: Sugar Free and Vegan for Some Pies

Exterior

Parking: Large Parking Lot / On Street Parking 

Visible Signage: From Road / Sign on Building 

Handicapped Accessible: Yes

Interior

Seating: Table and Outside Tables

Hostess on Duty: Yes

Gift Shop / Products for Sale: Yes - Aprons, Mitts, Mugs, and Kitchen Goods

Recommended Dishes

Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie, Mom’s Original Dutch Apple Pie, Cherry Lattice Pie, Peach Blueberry Lattice Pie, My Kentucky Pie, Pumpkin Pie